A bonanza for everyone?

Money from the state for everyone unconditionally – that is the aim of the popular initiative for an unconditional basic income which will be put to the vote on 5 June.

Everyone, regardless of whether they are in gainful employment or not and irrespective of their financial position, would receive a basic income. Those behind the initiative indicate an amount of CHF 2,500 a month for each adult. Children and young people up to the age of 18 would receive CHF 625.

The initiative does not explain exactly how this is to be financed. However, reflections on this matter are set out in supplementary documentation: Someone earning CHF 6,000 a month would only receive CHF 3,500 directly from their employer. CHF 2,500 from every salary would go into the basic income pot from which the employee would receive the remaining CHF 2,500. The basic income would also replace certain welfare benefits. However, the financing of the remainder is even contested by the advocates of the unconditional basic income.

The debate is heavily influenced by people’s different concepts of what it is to be human – do people essentially enjoy working? The authors of the initiative – primarily artists, journalists and intellectuals – are inclined to believe they do. In their view, few people would be content with an income of just CHF 2,500, which means the financial incentive of gainful employment would be maintained. The Federal Council rejects the proposal because it would have a “far-reaching, undesirable impact, in particular on the economic system and social cohesion”. A clear majority of MPs share this view. In the National Council, CVP spokesperson Ruth Humbel dubbed the initiative a “romantic social experiment”. The SP and Greens do not support the initiative either, apart from a few exceptions.

A global issue

Such opposition comes as little surprise. Unconditional basic income removes the model of paid work as the cornerstone of the economy and society. Many on the left also regard the initiative as a fundamental attack on the welfare state. This is because a uniform monthly pension of CHF 2,500 could never replace the tailored social insurance benefits that take account of the vicissitudes of life. There is also a fear that Parliament could initiate swingeing welfare cuts when it came to structuring the basic income in specific terms – the lowest possible basic income and the abolition of other welfare benefits. But that is precisely what makes unconditional basic income appealing to some neo-liberals. They see it as a means of cutting back the social insurance system.

This issue is not just being discussed in Switzerland. A restricted experiment with an unconditional basic income is to be conducted in Finland in 2017. Similar ideas are also being toyed with in France and the Netherlands.

Jürg Müller is an editor with THE “Swiss Review”

Comments (4)
  • Ernst  Ruetimann , Trang
    Ernst Ruetimann , Trang at 04.04.2016
    Ich dachte der Soziale Kommunismus waere mit dem Ende der UdSSR ausser Mode gekommen . Mit anderen Worten : es gibt nichts Neues unter der Sonne .-
    Show Translation
  • Goran Vasovic
    Goran Vasovic at 09.04.2016
    ich denke das ist Fair gegenüber die Steuerzahler und meine die wo wirklich Verhaltensleistung alle Jahre in der Schweiz sich korrekt verhalten haben und keine Schulden und Konkurse gegen über den staat zugefügt hat und anständig Steuer bezahlt hat dann bin ich Befürworter ja nur die Auszahlung soll durch die Steueramt den die wo auch schulden sollen direkten weg begünstigt sein mit abzahlen der Steuerschulden das wirklich auch fair alle davon haben die wo keine Schulden mehr haben warum nicht belohnen ..(Goran Vasovic Auslandschweizer) Serbien./ Prijepolje
    Show Translation
  • Guillermo J. Spescha
    Guillermo J. Spescha at 11.04.2016
    Para los suizo que vivan fuera del país, podrían obtener ese beneficio o no... Ya que yo estoy considerado como un suizo pero no vivo en Suiza.
    Show Translation
    • R.Grob
      R.Grob at 05.06.2016
      Show Translation

Write new comment

Comments are approved within one to three days. The editorial team reserves the right not to publish discriminatory, racist, defamatory or inflammatory comments. Our detailed comment rules are available here.

It is over a year since the Swiss National Bank abandoned the minimum rate against the euro. This has cost over 10,000 jobs to date and has halved...

Read more

The SNB’s task is to ensure price stability but prices have fallen with the end of the minimum rate. The economist Philippe Bacchetta explains why.

Read more

How should Swiss asylum policy be organised? The Swiss people will decide on this issue on 5 June 2016. The referendum forced by the SVP is likely to...

Read more

Gibt es ein Leben nach dem Tod? Wer weiss. Eines steht aber fest: Mit Sicherheit gibts einen lebendigen Tourismus nach dem Tod. Für Dahingeschiedene...

Read more

What is new in Ticino’s art scene? The MASI Lugano has been addressing this question for a number of years in its “Che c’è di nuovo?” exhibition...

Read more

Auslandschweizer Organisation
Alpenstrasse 26
3006 Bern, Schweiz

tel +41 31 356 61 10
fax +41 31 356 61 01