Uncompromising deportation

The SVP is seeking to apply its deportation initiative to the letter through an implementing initiative. Opponents warn of far-reaching consequences.

The Swiss People’s Party (SVP), deeply mistrusting “federal Berne” and suspecting the popular initiative “in favour of the deportation of foreign criminals” adopted in November 2010 would not be implemented to the letter, announced an implementing initiative just six months after the proposal’s approval. The bill will now be put to the vote on 28 February. The implementing law would be immediately enshrined in the constitution and would be directly applicable. This would restrict Parliament’s room for manoeuvre enormously and also infringe on the principle of the separation of powers, in the view of some experts.

The SVP is adopting an uncompromising position. This is despite the fact that Parliament, under pressure from the implementing initiative, has already passed a law that largely accommodates the wishes of those behind it. Criminal law has been significantly tightened in relation to the deportation of foreign criminals. It is practically identical to the deportation initiative. The only caveat is that Parliament takes account of the principle of proportionality with a hardship clause. This means that a court could refrain from deporting foreign criminals in individual cases if this would result in major personal hardship for the person concerned. The SVP believes that the amendment to the law adopted by Parliament would cement existing “lax deportation practices”, as it indicates on the party’s homepage. The courts would always find a reason to refrain from deportation.

Opponents warn that the adoption of the implementing initiative would also have ramifications for Switzerland’s relationship with the EU because the popular initiative expressly stipulates the precedence of national law over international law. If an EU citizen were deported for a minor offence, for example, the Agreement on the Free Movement of Persons with the EU would be violated. The adoption of the implementing initiative would therefore have implications extending far beyond criminal law. The initiative also departs from a previously generally recognised practice. Popular initiatives have until now hardly ever been implemented to the letter. Parliament has usually endeavoured to pass an implementing law that takes account of both the core requirements of those behind the initiative as well as other framework conditions – very much in line with the Swiss culture of compromise.

Comments (6)
  1. Erwin Balli-Ramos Erwin Balli-Ramos at 05.02.2016
    Das ist doch der klare Beweis, dass die SVP, wie immer, mit dem Ende des unteren Rückens denkt und politisiert. Denn
    Was wird passieren, wenn ein anderes Land den gleichen Unsinn per Gesetz einführt?
    Da reichen, dem im Lande lebenden Schweizer, zwei kleine Vergehen, z.B. einmal mit Übertoleranz erwischt und einmal den Hundekot nicht weggeräumt zu haben. Und schon muss man den Möbeltransporter
    anrufen.
    Wo bleibt denn da der gesunde Menschenverstand? Eben dort wo schon
    erwähnt.
  2. Alain Leuba Alain Leuba at 14.02.2016
    si nos fonctionnaires "fonctionnaient" de façon efficace (normale ?), il n'y aurait probablement pas tous ces problèmes. Le peuple est exaspéré de voir la lenteur des procédures. Accueillons bien ceux qui le méritent et renvoyons immédiatement les autres, c'est cela que le peuple veut, à quelques extrémistes près, de gauche ou de droite.
    La plus grande faute à toutes ces discussions est la très mauvaise prestation de l'administration.
  3. Alain Leuba Alain Leuba at 14.02.2016
    si nos fonctionnaires "fonctionnaient" de façon efficace (normale ?), il n'y aurait probablement pas tous ces problèmes. Le peuple est exaspéré de voir la lenteur des procédures. Accueillons bien ceux qui le méritent et renvoyons immédiatement les autres, c'est cela que le peuple veut, à quelques extrémistes près, de gauche ou de droite.
    La plus grande faute à toutes ces discussions est la très mauvaise prestation de l'administration.
  4. Alain Leuba Alain Leuba at 14.02.2016
    si nos fonctionnaires "fonctionnaient" de façon efficace (normale ?), il n'y aurait probablement pas tous ces problèmes. Le peuple est exaspéré de voir la lenteur des procédures. Accueillons bien ceux qui le méritent et renvoyons immédiatement les autres, c'est cela que le peuple veut, à quelques extrémistes près, de gauche ou de droite.
    La plus grande faute à toutes ces discussions est la très mauvaise prestation de l'administration.
  5. Madeline Murphy-Etter Madeline Murphy-Etter at 19.02.2016
    wenn ich in ein fremdes Land reise, so halte ich mich an die Regeln dieses Landes. So erwarte ich's auch von jenen die zu uns in die Schweiz kommen. Viel zu viel Gewicht gibt man dem Recht der Menschen anstatt der Verantwortung jedes Menschen. Fur Ordnung in unserem Land haben wir ein gezieltes Strafgesetz welches umgehend eingesetzt werden muss.
  6. Madeline Murphy-Etter Madeline Murphy-Etter at 19.02.2016
    wenn ich in ein fremdes Land reise, so halte ich mich an die Regeln dieses Landes. So erwarte ich's auch von jenen die zu uns in die Schweiz kommen. Viel zu viel Gewicht gibt man dem Recht der Menschen anstatt der Verantwortung jedes Menschen. Fur Ordnung in unserem Land haben wir ein gezieltes Strafgesetz welches umgehend eingesetzt werden muss.

Write new comment

The editorial team reserves the right to delete discriminatory, racist, defamatory or inflammatory comments or to block the comment function for this article.

Over 35,000 people sought asylum in Switzerland last year. The continuing flow of refugees is inevitably producing both sympathy and hostility and a...

Read more

The Swiss Confederation’s spending on asylum in 2015 passed 1.27 billion Swiss francs, with the cantons paying 600 million. Over the long term,...

Read more

The Swiss People’s Party has effortlessly gained a sought-after second Federal Council seat for Guy Parmelin. Is this sign of stability also a sign of...

Read more

Johann Schneider-Ammann’s transformation from business leader to politician is still not complete after five years on the Federal Council. Perhaps...

Read more

The world’s longest railway tunnel will go into operation by the middle of the year. Just a few months before that, on 28 February, the Swiss people...

Read more
 

Auslandschweizer Organisation
Alpenstrasse 26
3006 Bern, Schweiz

tel +41 31 356 61 10
fax +41 31 356 61 01
revue@aso.ch